Of personal identity david hume there are some philosophers who imagine we are every moment intimately. Locke and hume on personal identity locke and hume both discuss the idea of personal identity in connection with certain general claims about the very idea of identity in a more general sense and i am going to begin, prior to discussing personal identity in particular, with a comparison of their specific treatments of the general idea of identity. Since he had ceased to believe this by the time that he wrote the appendix, it might be a good thing to mention two relations which have a strong. It is not so clear, however, exactly what locke meant by consciousness or by having the same consciousness. Humes thoughts about personal identity try to first trace and consecutively explain psychological processes such as beliefs, sentiments, etc. Distinction between human beings and persons we need to clarify what we mean by the term person. His philosophy was that we as humans could only perceive, or imagine a concept of self based on various thoughts and images that we could see at any given time. In what follows i will argue that humes unpopularity is partly due to the fact that the theory is at odds with how we normally view identity, and partly due to the ambiguity of.
Humes discussion of personal identity is primarily built on the major. David hume on personal identity and the indirect passions. Terence penelhum, hume on personal identity philpapers. Person is a forensick term appropriating actions and their merit. These differ in the degrees of force and liveliness with which they. What makes you the same person as the little kid growing up a number of years ago. Apr 01, 2000 hume studies volume xxvi, number 1, april 2000, pp. Hume s account of personal identity does not satisfy philosophers dreams about perfect identity.
The treatment of personal identity in hume s treatise displays a shift that is both interesting as an object lesson in the weakness of a particular sort of empirical project, and important for what it teaches about investigating moral life. Hume s theory of personal identity is developed in response to lockes account of personal identity. Hume considered the idea of identity to be both fictitious and perception based hume, 1739. Hume s thoughts about personal identity try to first trace and consecutively explain psychological processes such as beliefs, sentiments, etc. David humes view on personal identity ask a philosopher. Pdf humans beings have no identical self researchgate. Berkeley and hume on self and selfconsciousness springerlink. The perception of self is a subjective interpretation of reality and is necessarily colored by the subjects own preconceived notions. Mar 25, 2018 david hume s philosophy on personal identity and bundle theory. Humes theory of the self and its identity dialogue. The origin of our ideas all the perceptions of the human mind fall into two distinct kinds, which i shall call impressions and ideas. Locke but once memory has done its work, then our personal identity can be extended even to times forgotten. The fifth part of professor dan robinsons series on reids critique of david hume.
While some have accused hume of rejecting personal identity, much in the way berkeley denies. Humes account of personal identity does not satisfy philosophers dreams about perfect identity. Since his contribution to the field of personal identity in 1738 humes theory has been debated thoroughly. Pdf based on previous thinkers such as john locke, the scottish philosopher david hume developed his own theory of personal identity, one that is.
One of the problems with humes discussion, that terence penelhum also raises in hume on personal identity, is that he does not seem to have a clear conception of the notion of identity. Humes discussion of personal identity is primarily built on the major role of the imagination, which it plays in the formation of belief. David hume, of personal identity from a treatise of human nature, 1739 there are some philosophers, who imagine we are every moment intimately conscious of what we call our self. Humes discussion on the personal identity philosophical. The evident connexion presents a new reading of hume s bundle theory of the self or mind, and his later rejection of it. From this formation of belief in general, we arrive at belief in causes, continued existence, and then on to the personal identity. Humes theory of personal identity is developed in response to lockes account of personal identity. Even today, argument rages as to what hume s view on personal identity really was. Granted that there are various poststructuralist approaches to the question of subjectivity, i. Introduction even philosophers who believe there is a single problem of personal identity conceive of that problem in different ways. Locke defines a mans personal identity as his consciousness, stating consciousness entails perceptions always being present in the mind, and therefore makes personal identity.
In what follows i will argue that hume s unpopularity is partly due to the fact that the theory is at odds with how we normally view identity, and partly due to the ambiguity of. Michael della rocca yale university explores some of the puzzles and problems of personal identity that arise from the. Rethinking humes second thoughts about personal identity may. Hume thought that this tendency goes a long way towards explaining mistaken views about personal identity.
In a paper called hume on personal identity, penelhum argues that humes account is an immense blunder, an excellent example of how complex and farreaching the consequences of a mistake in linguistic analysis or conceptual investigation can be. A question of humes theory of personal identity the oxford. Hume regards identity as a distinct idea of an object, that remains invariable and uninterrupted thro a supposd variation of time. But it is easy to see that they are different things, and the philosophical problem of personal identity is in fact concerned with only one of them particular identity. Regarding the issue of personal identity, 1 humes skeptical claim is that we have no experience of a simple, individual impression that we can call the selfwhere the self is the totality of a persons conscious life. The same consciousness is required for being the same person. David hume on personal identity a treatise concerning human nature 1739.
Printed for john noon, at the whitehart, near mercerschapel in cheapside. It is a widely held view among philosophers that humes doctrine of personal identity is seriously mistaken, that he makes claims about the existence and nature. Jul 12, 2014 the most significant features of hume s work, as understood by reid, are the representive theory of perception, the nature of causation and causal concepts, the nature of personal identity and the. It seems even more striking that humes account of self in books 2 and 3 of the treatise has less scope for distinguishing persons from human. Apr 23, 2012 hume s view of what constitutes personal identity rests heavily upon his preceding theories concerning the nature of ideas and causation. Locke provides the first comprehensive theory to deal with all of the issues to which the problem of personal identity is related p. It seems even more striking that hume s account of self in books 2 and 3 of the treatise has less scope for distinguishing persons from human. The evident connexion presents a new reading of humes bundle theory of the self or mind, and his later rejection of it. The strongest sensation, the most violent passion, say they. Rightly or wrongly, i take the view, with hume, that ones own identity. To understand what personal identity consists in, we must understand what the word person designates. Ideas, their origin, composition, connection, abstraction, etc.
A question of humes theory of personal identity the. And here tis evident, the same method of reasoning must be. Can we even give any explanation at all of the persistence of a person. For, he thought, when we encounter several different things existing in succession and differing gradually, one from the next. The treatment of personal identity in humes treatise displays a shift that is both interesting as an object lesson in the weakness of a particular sort of empirical project, and important for what it teaches about investigating moral life. Galen strawson argues that the bundle theory does not claim that there are no subjects of experience, as many have supposed, or that the mind is just a series of experiences. Hume believes that self is an illusion or a fiction. Being an attempt to introduce the experimental method of reasoning into moral subjects. Others treat personal identity in the context of theology or metaphysics or still even moral and legal issues p. Rethinking humes second thoughts about personal identity. David hume, a skeptic, takes a different approach to the idea of personal identity. In the previous section, he has rejected the ancient philosophys posit of a mental substance, or soul, in which the perceptions of the mind are said to inhere, and has argued that, in fact, each perception fits the definition of substance as something which may exist by itself.
For my part, when i enter most intimately into what i call myself, i always. Personal identity in shaftesbury and hume kenneth p. David hume believed that while people may have notions of some unchanging personal characteristics embedded within themselves, people have actually mistaken their perceptions of themselves as the genuine article. So complained david hume, who then went on to offer his conception of the self as an evolving bundle of. We now proceed to explain the nature of personal identity, which has become so great a question in philosophy, especially of late years in england, where all the abstruser sciences are studyd with a peculiar ardour and application. The objects of the mind vary along a single dimension of force and vivacity. According to hume, the self is composed of perceptions which are held within our memory, however memory is something we cant control. Sometimes we remember things, but they arent as clear and we do tend to forget somethings. He believed as we say nowadays, that his analysis of the concept of personal identity was correct. Hume s theory as described above seems easy to follow and very appealing, but hume s contribution to personal identity is generally not as popular as it deserves. Hume delivers his account of personal identity in treatise 1. Memory is essential to personal identity, as it is memory which allows us the impression of a continuity of perceptions, and so in turn, the idea of cause and effect.
Humes view of what constitutes personal identity rests heavily upon his preceding theories concerning the nature of ideas and causation. And here tis evident, the same method of reasoning must be continud. In conclusion hume s view on personal identity is in keeping with his sceptical approach, although he ultimately realizes he has in fact gone further than this strict approach allows, and that indeed he must do so. The most important preceding ideas to take into account are the rejection of causality and necessary connection and his strict empiric stance on the basis of knowledge and the only two types of perception being ideas that are. Hume studies volume xxvi, number 1, april 2000, pp.
Introduces the concept of personal identity, what is it to be a person, whether someone is the same person over time and leibnizs law of sameness. Galen strawson argues that the bundle theory does not claim that there are no subjects of experience, as many have supposed, or that. Of personal identity david hume there are some philosophers who imagine we are every moment intimately conscious of what we call our self. Yet it is striking that hume does not emphasize lockes distinction between persons and human beings. Defending humes theory of personal identity and discarding the. Personal identity variable element sound sleep present existence past perception. Hume on personal identity university of oxford podcasts. Locke on personal identity weinberg 2011 philosophy. The questions i wish to explore inthis paper pertain to the status of personal identity in the context of poststructuralist decenterings of subjectivity.
The section concerning personal identity to which humes appendix refersthn 1. David hume of personal identity flashcards quizlet. It is not so clear, however, exactly what locke meant by consciousness or. Download fulltext pdf download fulltext pdf hume and selfidentity article pdf available in discusiones filosoficas 1014. The most important preceding ideas to take into account are the rejection of causality and necessary connection and his strict empiric stance on the basis of knowledge and the only two types of perception being ideas that are reliant on initial impressions. For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription. Lockes account of personal identity has been highly influential because of its emphasis on a psychological criterion. For my part, when i enter most intimately into what i call myself, i always stumble on some particular perception or other, of heat or cold, light or shade, love or hatred, pain or pleasure. These two pieces of information are connected with one another, and in nigel denniss novel cards of identity the victims are deprived of both at once. The most significant features of humes work, as understood by reid, are the representive theory of perception, the nature of causation and causal concepts, the nature of personal identity and the. Sybil wolfram, hume on personal identity, mind, volume lxxxiii, issue 332, october 1974, pages 586593.
Is the identity of a person tied to the persistence of a body or a soul or something else entirely. What is the mind, self, or person to which identity and simplicity are attributed. Humes theory as described above seems easy to follow and very appealing, but humes contribution to personal identity is generally not as popular as it deserves. Personal identity, misc in metaphysics categorize this paper doi 10. Defending humes theory of personal identity and discarding.
651 477 1262 1656 1635 434 1539 1646 1441 207 449 323 1332 1173 1257 991 232 357 1392 269 674 1656 171 1480 615 1518 484 557 982 577 1140 1177 938 708 93 1344 984 694 1130 1065 504 1109